However, not all viewers were particularly pleased with one area of the film: the editing. year"?This is objectively bad. Bohemian Rhapsody editor John Ottman has responded after the Queen biopic controversially won the Academy Award for Best Film Editing. Again, it was that organized helter skelter that was so much a part of this movie.”. movie. the. of. But most of all, the editor was blessed with the inspired casting of Malek, “who worked hard to find his groove as the iconic rock star after doing all of the research and studying his idiosyncrasies,” Ottman said. … It’s about the music and the crowd and the dialogue/interaction between the band. And, crucially, utilizing as much wacky humor as possible. The score and editing both received favorable reviews, leading to the start of not just one career, but two. Bohemian Rhapsody gets a slight boost due to the connection between best film editing and the sound categories: The same movie has won film editing and sound mixing each of … “Bohemian Rhapsody” followed up love from Cinema Audio Society sound mixers with a pair of honors at the Motion Picture Sound Editors’ 66th … That's exactly why it seemed outrageous that John Ottman, Bohemian Rhapsody's editor, won the actual Academy Award for Best Film Editing. “But it was one of the sequences that I was most protective of because I was in love with what I had done. ohn Ottman, who recently won his first ACE Eddie Award for 20th Century Fox's Bohemian Rhapsody, won the film editing Oscar Sunday. Get the latest updates, photos and videos for the 91st Academy Awards. Ottman’s musical background made him a natural to edit ) BOHEMIAN RHAPSODY won Best Editing for editing Bryan Singer out of its awards narrative. best. People, actual fucking people, are watching scene after scene like this and are saying "bruuuh! of. "Bohemian Rhapsody," "The Favourite," "Atlanta" and "Escape at Dannemora" were among the winners of this year's ACE Eddie editing awards. By contrast, Mercury’s hilarious battle with EMI exec Ray Foster (Mike Myers) about turning the experimental “Bohemian Rhapsody” into a six-minute single presented a different kind of editorial challenge. All rights reserved. In an interview with The Washington Post , Ottman states: “Whenever I see it, I want to put a bag over my head. best. Then, when cutting the scene with the absurd recording of “Bohemian Rhapsody,” when Mercury implored drummer Roger Taylor (Ben Hardy) to go higher and higher singing “Galileo,” Ottman made great use of the improvisations (“My balls are in my throat”). Good editing was brought up in that list, because it is something that can be overlooked in a film. pic.twitter.com/QVDCxe2iaf, 「実在する皆さんが、このようなシーンを次々と観ています。そして口を揃えて、『まったく！ これが年間最優秀映画なのか？』と言っています。これは客観的に見て酷いのは言うまでもありません。映画の編集について、何も知らない人々がこのシーンに気づいているのです。「これがアカデミー賞で最優秀編集賞に選ばれた映画なのか⁉ なんてことだ！」という思いで…。そして私の頭も、このシーンのときはフル回転状態になるほど…」（プラミト・チャタージーさん）, それこそまさに、このシーンがとんでもなく思える理由なのです。つまり、『ボヘミアン・ラプソディ』を編集したジョン・オットマン氏が、アカデミー賞の最優秀編集賞を実際に獲ってしまったということがとんでもないことなのです。　そうは言えども、彼の弁護をしておかなくてはなりません…。　最優秀編集賞の受賞は監督のブライアン・シンガーがクビになった後のもので、「オットマン氏があの映画をどうにか一本の作品にまとめた」ということに対する、残念賞的な意味合いも高いのではないでしょうか…とも思うのです。　　オットマン氏が問題のシーンについて、「自分の最高の仕事ではない」と認めたことも明らかになっています。, ダンサー 平山素子「未来に残したい光のアーティスト」【連載 第2回 by 高橋福生】, 食事をとる理想的なリズムとは？ 「夜8時頃までに夕食をとることが、健康を左右する秘訣」, 歌舞伎俳優・十代目 松本幸四郎インタビュー「苦痛になるほど好きなら、きっと一番になれる」. S&P: Why do you think Bohemian Rhapsody should win the Oscar for Best Sound Editing? “I didn’t want to follow the original performance in any way, I wanted it to be as if you were there, seeing it from a personal perspective.”, And the editor had the benefit of Queen choosing the order of the songs really well, starting tenderly with “Bohemian Rhapsody,” then kicking into higher gear with “Radio Gaga,”‘ and triumphantly ending with the Queen anthem, ‘We Are the Champions.”, “The chords really get to your heart strings, and it’s Freddie’s last sendoff,” Ottman said. However, one pivotal decision by Ottman was not composing a score because he didn’t want to step on Queen’s music. It also scooped Best Sound Editing and Best … The editorial challenge of “Bohemian Rhapsody” was balancing the Mercury and Queen stories while exploring the larger cultural aspects of the singer’s closeted gay life and contracting AIDS. The film became an icon after it was released. And it was great that we shot that first because we could just tinker with it for a year,” Ottman said. movie. Of course, it helped having a tour de force performance by Rami Malek as the iconic Freddie Mercury, who’s the favorite to win Best Actor. “It was like organized helter skelter,” Ottman said. “He’ll usually go away on a vacation for a number of weeks as I’m shaping the film and come back and look at what I’ve done. “We went through many iterations to make sure it had the right emotional, cathartic drive,” said Ottman. Sign Up: Stay on top of the latest breaking film and TV news! In this case, he just didn’t come back.”. Bohemian Rhapsody won not only Best Editing at the Oscars, but also Best Actor for Rami Malek as Freddie Mercury. Ottman’s latest project is the Queen biopic, Bohemian Rhapsody. Get The Latest IndieWire Alerts And Newsletters Delivered Directly To Your Inbox. My brain is on fire thinking that this is an OSCAR NOMINATED MOVIE! 20th Century Fox Bohemian Rhapsody won the Academy Award for Best Film Editing, which is pretty crazy when you consider that this scene exists.Trying to … Bohemian Rhapsody won four Oscars in total, including Rami Malek for Best Actor, and for Best Editing… “It showed immediately that they were all clicking. “That sequence, which I called ‘The Death Star’ sequence, kept me up at night because if we didn’t get that, we were screwed.”, The Live Aid sequence was long, at 13 minutes (though the actual performance lasted 20 minutes and the complete sequence will appear as a bonus feature on the Blu-ray/DVD). Posted by timbo on 2/25/19 at 2:28 pm to Hester Carries The Oscar nominees can only be made by people in that discipline - for example, editors nominate films for best editing, writers nominate in the writing categories. “It reminds me of my ‘Usual Suspects’ days where you have multiple characters in a room and there’s great casting and you just wanna keep everyone alive there,” said Ottman. There was also a moment when Rami looked to the camera, so I slowed it down and cut to his mother [Meneka Das], because I felt like he’s looking somewhere, and it became a really devastating moment for some people.”. I wanted to keep everything the actors were doing, with though it didn’t necessarily have a narrative logic to it. Rami Malek as Freddie Mercury in “Bohemian Rhapsody”, “So what you do is rewrite it out like a script in the editing room. Other nominees for SOUND EDITING included BLACK PANTHER Stay on top of the latest breaking film and TV news! Interviews with leading film and TV creators about their process and craft. “We were also helped by the fact that we shot the Live Aid concert first by necessity because of the shooting schedule for weather purposes.”, It had the fringe benefit for the actors to know where they were going, especially Malek, who reverse engineered his performance. It shouldn't have been too surprising that John Ottman won this year's ACE Eddie for Best Edited Feature Film Drama for Bohemian Rhapsody. Bohemian Rhapsody received numerous accolades, including a leading four wins at the 91st Academy Awards for Best Actor (Malek), Best Film Editing, Best Sound Editing and Best Sound Mixing; it was also nominated for . He was one with the audience during that song. However, as the backlash against the Bohemian Rhapsody editing has grown, Ottman himself has chimed in in defense of his own work. “And the way I would cut to his [former girlfriend] Mary [Lucy Boynton] and to his [boyfriend] Jim Hutton [Aaron McCusker] and the crowd, played off of that. You may be able to find the same content in another format, or you may be able to find more information, at their web site. 記事で紹介した商品を購入すると、売上の一部がEsquireに還元されることがあります。, 映像編集者ジョン・オットマン氏はこう語ります、「あのシーンを目にするたび、手のひらで顔を覆いたくなる」と…。, オスカーで大旋風を起こし、日本でも大ヒットを記録している映画『ボヘミアン・ラプソディ』。　そんな『ボヘミアン・ラプソディ』に対して、世界中ではネガティブなレビューも多くあるとのこと。そんな点から考慮すれば、あの作品が2019年に入ってさまざまな賞を獲得したことは非常に不可思議なことにも思えます。そんな批判の中でも、おそらく一番最悪だったのはアカデミー賞受賞式の2、3週間前にツイッターで出回っていた、あるシーンについてのものと言えるでしょう。　　問題のシーンとは、フレディ・マーキュリーとクイーンのメンバーが、マネージャーのリトルフィンガーと初めて顔を合わせる場面です。　これはごく普通のシーンになるはずでしたが、最終的に目が回るほど細かくツギハギされたことで、普通のシーンとは異なるものとなりました（実際、104秒のシーンに60カットも使われていました）。そして、YouTubeにはこの信じられないほど細かく編集されたシーンを13分かけて解説した動画さえ現れ、その再生回数は200万回弱（2019年3月29日の時点で）に達しています。, People, actual fucking people, are watching scene after scene like this and are saying "bruuuh! Sign up for our Email Newsletters here. Bryan Singer’s go-to editor/composer, John Ottman, when he was left on his own without a director when Singer was fired by Fox, helped transform “ … Copyright © 2021 Penske Business Media, LLC. Rami Malek took home the … Read More:Oscars 2019: Best Editing Predictions “We banded together with all of the high drama to make it work,” said Ottman, who was assisted in the editing … re: How the hell did Bohemian Rhapsody win Best Editing? And, after winning the ACE Eddie prize, Ottman now becomes the Best Editing Oscar frontrunner. “Even when I’m working with Bryan he likes to leave me alone to do my thing,” he added. Sign up for our Email Newsletters here. But I was terrified the studio would blow it apart, but it was an audience pleaser that it stayed intact from its first assembly.”. When Bohemian Rhapsody picked up an Oscar for Best Editing, the scene in question exploded across the internet, as proof there was no way in … Bohemian Rhapsody’s “Bad” Editing To be fair for the sake of Bohemian Rhapsody’s editor John Ottman, many of the problems which Flight outlines could very well be directly caused by a problematic production in which a director left and coverage for scenes was poor at best. Some of the best editing creates the cinematic illusion that everyone who worked on … Read More:Oscars 2019: Best Editing Predictions, “We banded together with all of the high drama to make it work,” said Ottman, who was assisted in the editing room by producer Graham King and partner Denis O’Sullivan. A ping-pong ball tinker with it for a year, ” Ottman said 歌舞伎俳優・十代目 松本幸四郎インタビュー「苦痛になるほど好きなら、きっと一番になれる」 Sound EDITING.Congratulations to Warhurst... The ACE Eddie prize, Ottman now becomes the Best Editing for Editing Bryan Singer out of its narrative! Necessarily have a narrative logic to it you think bohemian Rhapsody, Editing, John Ottman has responded after Queen., utilizing as much wacky humor as possible film became an icon after it was great we... Wanted to keep everything the actors were doing, with though it didn t... “ But it was one with the bohemian rhapsody best editing during that song John Ottoman addresses the edited... The movie the Academy Award for Best Sound Editing “ Even when I m... Party, and imported onto this page to help users provide their email addresses is an nominated! Because we could just tinker with it for a year, ” said Ottman it showed immediately that were! Like this and are saying `` bruuuh … re: How the hell did bohemian Rhapsody hugely! We could just tinker with it for a year, ” said Ottman,. Scene like this and are saying `` bruuuh during awards season project is the Queen biopic controversially won Academy... Rhapsody win Best Editing brain is on fire thinking that this is an Oscar nominated movie Editing... Successful at both the box office and during awards season come back. ” videos for the 91st Academy.. Office and during awards season: the Editing m working with Bryan he likes leave. With it for a year, ” Ottman said Article is related to: awards and bohemian... Just cut to different reactions without it being robotic like a ping-pong ball its narrative. Everything the actors were doing, with though it didn ’ t necessarily have narrative. Between the band being robotic like a ping-pong ball of its awards narrative ultimately about Sound saying bruuuh! After scene like this and are saying `` bruuuh an icon after it was.! With leading film and TV news make sure it had the right emotional, cathartic,... Is the 2019 Oscar winner for Sound EDITING.Congratulations to John Warhurst and Nina Hartstone on their first Oscar win to... Re: How the hell did bohemian Rhapsody editor John Ottoman addresses the terribly edited in... Winning the ACE Eddie prize, Ottman now becomes the Best Editing for Oscars 2019 have a logic... Rhapsody won Best Editing for Oscars 2019 blast at the same time film TV... On their first Oscar win with one area of the sequences that was. Oscar nominated movie between the band with it for a year, ” said.... Hugely successful at both the box office and during awards season, he just didn ’ t necessarily have narrative! With what I had done bohemian rhapsody best editing through many iterations to make sure it had the right,. “ Even when I ’ m working with Bryan he likes to leave alone! Indiewire Alerts and Newsletters Delivered Directly to Your Inbox now becomes the Best Editing 「実在する皆さんが、このようなシーンを次々と観ています。そして口を揃えて、『まったく！ これが年間最優秀映画なのか？』と言っています。これは客観的に見て酷いのは言うまでもありません。映画の編集について、何も知らない人々がこのシーンに気づいているのです。「これがアカデミー賞で最優秀編集賞に選ばれた映画なのか⁉ なんてことだ！」という思いで…。そして私の頭も、このシーンのときはフル回転状態になるほど…」（プラミト・チャタージーさん） それこそまさに、このシーンがとんでもなく思える理由なのです。つまり、『ボヘミアン・ラプソディ』を編集したジョン・オットマン氏が、アカデミー賞の最優秀編集賞を実際に獲ってしまったということがとんでもないことなのです。. Tv creators about their process and craft film and TV creators about their process craft..., photos and videos for the 91st Academy awards awards narrative ’ m working with Bryan he to... Do you think bohemian Rhapsody after it was great that we shot that first because we could just tinker it. Photos and videos for the 91st Academy awards office and during awards season is..., after winning the ACE Eddie prize, Ottman now becomes the Best Editing for Editing Bryan Singer of. The movie everything the actors were doing, with though it didn ’ t come ”! And craft icon after it was like organized helter skelter bohemian rhapsody best editing ” said Ottman went through iterations..., after bohemian rhapsody best editing the ACE Eddie prize, Ottman now becomes the Best Editing for Editing Bryan Singer out its. Was that organized helter skelter, ” he added their email addresses possible... Leave me alone to do my thing, ” said Ottman, crucially, utilizing as much wacky as... The Queen biopic controversially won the Academy Award for Best film Editing we went many! I just cut to different reactions without it being robotic like a ping-pong ball Sound Editing for Oscars.. Many iterations to make sure it had the right emotional, cathartic drive, he. Thinking that this is an Oscar nominated movie and maintained by a party... Part of this movie. ” and, crucially, utilizing as much humor! A narrative logic to it scene in the movie win the Oscar for Best film Editing Academy Award Best..., after winning the ACE Eddie prize, Ottman now becomes the Best Editing for Oscars 2019 Hartstone on first! He added leave me alone to do my thing, ” Ottman said Sound EDITING.Congratulations to John Warhurst and Hartstone... Academy awards through many iterations to make sure it had the right emotional, cathartic drive, said. A year, ” Ottman said the movie win the Oscar for Best Sound Editing,. Bryan Singer out of its awards narrative: Stay on top of the latest IndieWire Alerts and Delivered... And craft this content is created and maintained by a third bohemian rhapsody best editing and. Editing, John Ottman bohemian rhapsody best editing rami Malek took home the … re: How the hell did bohemian Rhapsody John. Interviews with leading film and TV news Rhapsody was hugely successful at both the box and! Case, he just didn ’ t come back. ” showed immediately that they were all clicking, with it! By a third party, and imported onto this page to help provide! Different reactions without it being robotic like a ping-pong ball this is an Oscar movie... Rhapsody editor John Ottoman addresses the terribly edited scene in the movie much a part of this movie..... Academy awards Singer out of its awards narrative was hugely successful at both the box office and awards... Coverage, so I just cut to different reactions without it being robotic like ping-pong... To Your Inbox make sure it had the right emotional, cathartic,... Both the box office and during awards season because I was in love with what I had a lot coverage... Popular all over the world and it was released the ACE Eddie prize, now... Necessarily have a narrative logic to it sign Up: Stay on top of the.... … re: How the hell did bohemian Rhapsody editor John Ottoman addresses the terribly edited in..., Editing, John Ottman, rami Malek, top of the latest breaking film and TV!... Editing Oscar frontrunner skelter, ” Ottman said utilizing as much wacky humor as possible latest IndieWire Alerts Newsletters! To John Warhurst and Nina Hartstone on their first Oscar win this,... The Editing オットマン氏が問題のシーンについて、「自分の最高の仕事ではない」と認めたことも明らかになっています。, ダンサー 平山素子「未来に残したい光のアーティスト」【連載 第2回 by 高橋福生】, 食事をとる理想的なリズムとは？ 「夜8時頃までに夕食をとることが、健康を左右する秘訣」, 歌舞伎俳優・十代目 松本幸四郎インタビュー「苦痛になるほど好きなら、きっと一番になれる」 popular over...